Tell Me Why I'm Wrong

A bi-weekly show featuring two friends setting each other straight about history, politics, philosophy, and everything else.

About the show

Each episode, we do two segments, with one of us starting off with a confident but possibly erroneous take on a subject and the challenge to “Tell me why I’m wrong.” Then we switch. We learn, and hopefully you do, too.

Tell Me Why I'm Wrong on social media

Episodes

  • S3E6: So Long and Thanks for All the Fish

    May 7th, 2018  |  1 hr 5 mins

    Sophie and Amos wrap up Season 3 with an all fish-sex episode! They mostly talk about Guillermo Del Toro's new-ish film The Shape of Water, but they also throw in some talk about H.P. Lovecraft's short story The Shadow Over Innsmouth.

  • S3E5: Human Behavior

    April 30th, 2018  |  1 hr 11 mins

    Sophie asks Amos what the deal is with behaviorism in psychology. Amos asks Sophie about the relationship between liberalism and nationalism in 19th Century Europe.

  • S3E4: Homework, Part 2

    April 2nd, 2018  |  1 hr 3 mins

    Sophie and Amos are back at it. They making each other read some stuff that they ambivalent about. Sophie makes Amos read Two Years, Eight Months, and Twenty-Eight Nights by Salman Rushdie and Amos assigns a whole bunch of H.P. Lovecraft short stories.

  • S3E3: Secret Ingredients

    February 12th, 2018  |  1 hr 11 mins

    Sophie and Amos are at it again, this time talking about what the deal with translation is, and revisiting S1E1 with a conversation about the science of nutrition.

  • S3E2: Movies vs. Television

    January 29th, 2018  |  1 hr 6 mins

    Sophie loves TV. Amos loves Movies. Only one can be right!

  • S3E1: Art & Experience

    January 15th, 2018  |  1 hr 12 mins

    Sophie and Amos are back! They kick off Season 3 talking about the pros and cons of the fourth wall and then move into HEATED discussion of phenomenology!

  • Season 2 Bonus: Wonder Woman!

    August 14th, 2017  |  1 hr 7 mins

    Sophie and Amos are back for a chat about the movie Wonder Woman. They talked about it a little bit back in S1E3, and follow up now that they've actually seen it. This episode is FULL OF SPOILERS!

  • S2E6: Reductions

    August 1st, 2017  |  1 hr 4 mins

    Sophie and Amos really tell each other why they're wrong this time! Sophie is wrong about words having meanings, and Amos is wrong about all cultural change being technological change.

  • S2E5: Homework

    July 4th, 2017  |  1 hr 29 mins

    Sophie and Amos talk about the stuff they were assigned to watch. Amos asks Sophie about some movies by Guillermo Del Toro. Sophie asks Amos about Community, created by Dan Harmon.

  • S2E4: Ancient Greece, Which was in Europe, is (was) Not America

    June 11th, 2017  |  49 mins 35 secs

    Sophie and Amos record secret content that they refuse to share with you. They discuss how Amos relates everything to the Iliad, specifically Chris Hayes's book Twilight of the Elites.

  • S2E3: National Pastimes

    May 8th, 2017  |  1 hr 12 mins

    Amos and Sophie discuss two activities that bind this nation together: arguing about politics and watching TV.

  • S2E2: We Hate Science

    April 20th, 2017  |  1 hr 7 mins

    Sophie and Amos are angry and they know who to blame: science! Amos is angry about the nexus of science and identity politics. Sophie just hates science.

  • S2E1: Hobby Horses

    April 3rd, 2017  |  1 hr 13 mins

    Sophie asks Amos how to have hobbies and Amos wants Sophie to explain how to stay interested in something for more than six months. Typhus!

  • Season 1 Bonus: L'Esprit d'Escalier

    February 27th, 2017  |  1 hr 14 mins

    Sophie and Amos do the numbers on Season 1 and tie up a few loose ends. As usual, there's a lot of talk about Nazis.

  • S1E6: Ways of (Not) Knowing Redux

    February 15th, 2017  |  1 hr 5 mins

    Sophie and Amos return to discuss different ways of understanding the world. Amos explains what's wrong with obsessing about statistical models for understanding politics, and Sophie unloads on historical analogies.

  • S1E5: Self & Other

    January 30th, 2017  |  1 hr 21 mins

    Zen and the Art of Political Revolution. Not the title of some douchey business book, but our topics for this episode. Amos sets Sophie straight on what the deal with Zen is, and Sophie sets Bernie Sanders straight on what the deal with Democratic Socialism is.